Why Google is deleting reviews at record levels

In 2025, Google is removing reviews from business profiles faster than ever before. This is neither accidental nor a temporary technical issue, but the result of structural changes in moderation practices, automation, and legal enforcement.

According to an industry analysis of more than 60,000 Google Business Profiles, the surge in review deletions is driven by a combination of automated moderation, industry-specific risk levels, stricter enforcement against incentivized reviews, and growing local regulatory pressure. Together, these factors are reshaping local visibility and directly affecting local SEO strategies.

A Global Increase in Review Deletions

Data collected from tens of thousands of business profiles across multiple countries shows a sharp rise in deleted reviews between January and July 2025. The acceleration began toward the end of Q1 and intensified mid-year, with a growing number of locations experiencing at least one review removal per week.

Notably, this trend is not limited to negative feedback. While one-star reviews continue to be removed, five-star reviews now represent a substantial share of deletions. This shift indicates a significantly stricter approach to authenticity checks, particularly regarding positive feedback.

An additional signal of this enforcement is Google’s recent practice of asking members of its Local Guide community whether businesses are incentivizing reviews. These prompts are likely triggered by AI-based systems flagging suspicious review patterns.

Industry-Specific Differences in Moderation

The intensity of review deletions varies considerably by business category.

The highest volumes of deleted reviews are observed in:

• restaurants,
• home services,
• brick-and-mortar retail,
• construction.

These sectors generate large numbers of reviews, and removals affect both recent and older submissions. This distribution suggests ongoing enforcement rather than isolated cleanup initiatives.

By contrast, medical services, beauty, and professional services show lower overall deletion volumes. However, deeper analysis reveals consistent internal patterns that point to qualitative, rather than purely quantitative, moderation differences.

What Deleted Review Ratings Reveal About Industry Risk

When deleted reviews are analyzed by rating distribution, clear indicators of industry risk profiles emerge.

In restaurants and general retail, deletions are relatively evenly spread across one- to five-star ratings. In contrast, medical and home services categories show a strong skew toward five-star review removals, with very few deletions among mid-range ratings.

This pattern suggests heightened scrutiny of positive reviews in regulated or higher-risk industries, where trust, safety, and compliance are particularly sensitive. These outcomes do not appear to result from manual, category-specific policy decisions, but rather from automated systems dynamically adjusting enforcement based on perceived industry risk.

Timing Matters: Early vs. Retroactive Deletions

The age of a review plays a significant role in determining when it is removed.

In medical and home services, a large proportion of deleted reviews disappear within the first six months after posting. This points to early intervention by automated systems that evaluate review language, reviewer behavior, account history, and other risk signals.

Restaurants and brick-and-mortar retail follow a different pattern. Many deleted reviews in these categories are more than two years old, indicating retroactive enforcement as detection systems improve or new suspicious relationships are identified. This may also reflect broader efforts to refresh older review profiles.

For businesses, this means that reviews can be removed long after publication, often without warning.

Geography and Legal Context

Industry alone does not fully explain review deletion behavior. Geography plays a critical role.

In English-speaking markets such as the United States, the United Kingdom, Canada, and Australia, deleted reviews are disproportionately five-star ratings. This aligns with AI-driven efforts to reduce review spam and incentivized positive feedback.

Germany stands out as a notable exception. Analysis of thousands of German business listings shows that a higher share of deleted reviews are low-rated and are typically removed within weeks of posting. This pattern is consistent with Germany’s strict defamation laws, which allow businesses to legally challenge negative reviews and require platforms to act promptly upon notification.

In summary:

• AI-driven enforcement dominates in most English-speaking markets.
• Legal takedowns play a significantly larger role in Germany.

Implications for Local SEO and Businesses

The rise in review deletions presents two major challenges.

First, trust erosion. When legitimate reviews—positive or negative—disappear without explanation, confidence in review platforms weakens among both users and businesses.

Second, data distortion. Deleted reviews directly affect star ratings, historical performance trends, benchmarks, and conversion signals that businesses rely on for local SEO and reputation management.

As a result, review monitoring is no longer optional. Businesses must not only focus on generating new reviews but also understand which reviews are removed, when this happens, and under what conditions.

The Forces Reshaping Review Visibility

Three key developments are redefining how reviews remain visible:

1. Expanded automated moderation using AI, applied both in real time and retroactively.
2. Increased influence of local legal frameworks, particularly in regions with strict defamation laws.
3. Growing reliance on third-party monitoring tools as businesses seek independent records of review deletions.

In this evolving environment, sentiment alone no longer guarantees review longevity. For local SEO, authentic, detailed, and context-rich reviews—especially recent ones—remain a critical authority signal for both users and search engines.

Staying ahead now requires a dual focus: consistently collecting new reviews while closely tracking and understanding removals as part of a comprehensive reputation management strategy.

Read this article in Ukrainian.